Restaurants
New (opened between Feb. ’24–Jan. ’25)
Winner: Pretty Boy
247 Prince Ave. · 706-850-0938
Runner Up: Preacher Green’s
1995 Barnett Shoals Rd. · 706-215-9079
Italian
Winner: ZZ & Simone’s
1540 S. Lumpkin St., Ste. 4 · 706-395-6556
Runner Up: DePalma’s Italian Cafe
401 E. Broad St. · 706-354-6966
1965 Barnett Shoals Rd. · 706-369-0085
2080 Timothy Rd. · 706-552-1237
American
Winner: Clocked!
259 W. Washington St. · 706-548-9175
Runner Up: Hi-Lo Lounge
1354 Prince Ave. · 706-850-8561
Asian
Winner: Puma Yu’s
355 Oneta St., Ste. D-400 · www.pumayus.com
Runner Up: Pretty Boy
247 Prince Ave. · 706-850-0938
Sushi
Winner: Shokitini
251 W. Clayton St. · 706-353-7933
Runner Up: Chuck’s Fish
220 W. Broad St. · 706-395-6611
Mexican/Latin American
Winner: Cali-N-Tito’s
1427 S. Lumpkin St. · 706-227-9979
1245 Cedar Shoals Dr. · 706-355-7087
Runner Up: Tlaloc El Mexicano Restaurant
1225 N. Chase St. · 706-613-9301
International
Winner: Mannaweenta
1055 Gaines School Rd. · 706-850-8422
Runner Up: Taste of India
1040 Gaines School Rd., Ste. 119 · 706-559-0000
BBQ
Winner: Dawg Gone Good BBQ
224 W. Hancock Ave. · 706-613-9799
Runner Up: White Tiger
217 Hiawassee Ave. · 706-353-6847
64 Main St., Watkinsville · 706-705-6115
Bakery
Winner: Independent Baking Co.
1625 S. Lumpkin St. · 706-850-3550
Runner Up: Sweetie Pie by Savie
150 E. Whitehall Rd. · 706-850-9255
Downhome/Southern
Winner: Preacher Green’s
1995 Barnett Shoals Rd. · 706-215-9079
Runner Up: South Kitchen and Bar
247 E. Washington St. · 706-395-6125
Local Coffee House
Winner: Jittery Joe’s Coffee
1860 Barnett Shoals Rd. · 706-354-8000
1480 Baxter St. · 706-548-1099
1230 S. Milledge Ave. · 706-208-1979
150 Fitz Mar Ln. · 706-227-2161
297 E. Broad St. · 706-613-7449
1880 Epps Bridge Pkwy. · 706-345-8900
Runner Up: Sips Espresso Cafe
1390 Prince Ave. · 706-363-7211
Local Pizza
Winner: Automatic Pizza
1397 Prince Ave. · 706-850-2037
Runner Up: Little Italy
125 N. Lumpkin St. · 706-613-7100
Local Burger
Winner: Clocked!
259 W. Washington St. · 706-548-9175
Runner Up: Baddies Burgers
1591 S. Lumpkin St. · 706-850-8331
1011 Park Dr., Watkinsville · 706-705-6032
Fries
Winner: Hi-Lo Lounge
1354 Prince Ave. · 706-850-8561
Runner Up: Trappeze Pub
269 W. Washington St. · 706-543-8997
Burrito
Winner: Barberitos Southwestern Grille and Cantina
259 E. Clayton St. · 706-549-9008
1860 Barnett Shoals Rd. · 706-549-9954
1880 Epps Bridge Pkwy. · 706-354-0300
1739 S. Lumpkin St. · 706-548-1866
680 N. Hwy 29 · 706-543-5299
Runner Up: Paloma Park
235 W. Washington St. · 706-850-7356
Taco
Winner: Paloma Park
235 W. Washington St. · 706-850-7356
Runner Up: Taqueria del Sol
334 Prince Ave. · 706-353-3890
Steak
Winner: Slater’s Steakhouse
1653 S. Lumpkin St. · 706-395-6082
Runner Up: Porterhouse Grill
459 E. Broad St. · 706-369-0990
Seafood
Winner: Seabear Oyster Bar
297 Prince Ave., Ste. 10 · 706-850-4367
Runner Up: Chuck’s Fish
220 W. Broad St. · 706-395-6611
Wings
Winner: Paloma Park
235 W. Washington St. · 706-850-7356
Runner Up: Blind Pig Tavern
312 E. Washington St. · 706-548-3442
2440 W. Broad St. · 706-208-7979
Vegetarian Options
Winner: Hi-Lo Lounge
1354 Prince Ave. · 706-850-8561
Runner Up: Maepole
1021 N. Chase St. · 706-850-3600
1850 Epps Bridge Pkwy. · 706-510-3133
Sandwich
Winner: Hi-Lo Lounge
1354 Prince Ave. · 706-850-8561
Runner Up: Birdie’s
497 Prince Ave. · 706-850-1711
Dessert
Winner: Last Resort Grill
184 W. Clayton St. · 706-549-0810
Runner Up: Condor Chocolates
1658 S. Lumpkin St. · 706-850-4803
160 E. Washington St. · 706-521-8966
Bubble Tea
Winner: Bubble Cafe
247 E. Broad St. · 706-355-3002
Runner Up: Taichi Bubble Tea
151 E. Broad St. · 706-395-6483
Ice Cream/ Frozen Treat
Winner: Jeni’s Ice Creams
1710 Lumpkin St. · 706-493-7377
Runner Up: Andy’s Frozen Custard
2180 W. Broad St. · 762-356-4330
Breakfast
Winner: Mama’s Boy
197 Oak St. · 706-548-6249
8851 Macon Hwy. · 706-850-8550
1725 Electric Ave., Watkinsville
Runner Up: Cafe Racer
2343 W. Broad St. · 706-850-0297
Lunch
Winner: Paloma Park
235 W. Washington St. · 706-850-7356
Runner Up: Marti’s at Midday
1280 Prince Ave. · 706-543-3541
Brunch
Winner: Big City Bread
393 N. Finley St. · 706-353-0029
Runner Up: Mama’s Boy
197 Oak St. · 706-548-6249
8851 Macon Hwy. · 706-850-8550
1725 Electric Ave., Watkinsville
Special Occasion
Winner: The National
232 W. Hancock Ave. · 706-549-3450
Runner Up: Five & Ten
1073 S. Milledge Ave. · 706-546-7300
Catering
Winner: Marti’s at Midday
1280 Prince Ave. · 706-543-3541
Runner Up: Paloma Park
235 W. Washington St. · 706-850-7356
Meal for a Deal
Winner: Paloma Park
235 W. Washington St. · 706-850-7356
Runner Up: Taco Stand
2230 Barnett Shoals Rd. · 706-549-5481
670 N. Milledge Ave. · 706-549-2894
Kid-Friendly Local Restaurant
Winner: Ted’s Most Best
254 W. Washington St. · 706-543-1523
Runner Up: Cali-N-Tito’s
1427 S. Lumpkin St. · 706-227-9979
1245 Cedar Shoals Dr. · 706-355-7087
Outdoor Dining
Winner: Cali-N-Tito’s
1427 S. Lumpkin St. · 706-227-9979
1245 Cedar Shoals Dr. · 706-355-7087
Runner Up: Ted’s Most Best
254 W. Washington St. · 706-543-1523
Take Out
Winner: Maepole
1021 N. Chase St. · 706-850-3600
1850 Epps Bridge Pkwy. · 706-510-3133
Runner Up: Thai Spoon
149 N. Lumpkin St. · 706-548-9222
Chef
Winner: Kenny Nguyen
at Pretty Boy
489 E. Clayton St. · 706-543-8898
Runner Up: Pete Amadhanirundr
at Puma Yu’s
355 Oneta St., Ste. D-400 · www.pumayus.com
Uniquely Athens Restaurant
Winner: Cali-N-Tito’s
1427 S. Lumpkin St. · 706-227-9979
1245 Cedar Shoals Dr. · 706-355-7087
Runner Up: Hi-Lo Lounge
1354 Prince Ave. · 706-850-8561
Bars
Bartender
Winner: Ally Smith at Puma Yu’s
355 Oneta St., Ste. D-400 · www.pumayus.com
Richard Mikulka at Flicker
263 W. Washington St. · 706-546-0039
Runner Up: Atanas Kushlev at Paloma Park
235 W. Washington St. · 706-850-7356
Specialty Drinks
Winner: The Old Pal
1320 Prince Ave. · 706-850-4340
Runner Up: Puma Yu’s
355 Oneta St., Ste. D-400 · www.pumayus.com
Happy Hour
Winner: Paloma Park
235 W. Washington St. · 706-850-7356
Runner Up: Seabear Oyster Bar
297 Prince Ave., Ste. 10 · 706-850-4367
Beer Selection
Winner: Hi-Lo Lounge
1354 Prince Ave. · 706-850-8561
Runner Up: Trappeze Pub
269 W. Washington St. · 706-543-8997
Wine Selection
Winner: The Lark Winespace
493 Prince Ave. · 706-850-5455
Runner Up: Tapped Athens
297 Prince Ave. · 404-538-4369
Local Brewery
Winner: Creature Comforts Brewery
271 W. Hancock Ave. · 706-410-1043
Runner Up: Athentic Brewing Company
108 Park Ave. · 706-206-2074
Outdoor Bar Space
Winner: Paloma Park
235 W. Washington St. · 706-850-7356
Runner Up: Creature Comforts Brewery
271 W. Hancock Ave. · 706-410-1043
Place to Play Games
Winner: The Rook and Pawn
294 W. Washington St. · 706-543-5040
Runner Up: Wonderbar
240 E. Washington St. · @wonderbarwonderbar
Uniquely Athens Bar
Winner: Hidden Gem 625 Barber St., Ste. 140 · @hiddengemglobalhq
Runner Up: Manhattan Cafe
337 N. Hull St. · 706-369-9767
Like what you just read? Support Flagpole by making a donation today. Every dollar you give helps fund our ongoing mission to provide Athens with quality, independent journalism.
